The Lovenhall RegistryThe LovenhallRegistry
Amethyst · Lovenhall Stone

How to Identify Amethyst Geode & Cathedral

The hollow lined with crystal points. Where dyed and 'enhanced' material shows up most.

Brazil, Uruguay, Zambia, Madagascar, Arizona3 references

A geode is a cavity in volcanic rock lined with crystals grown inwards from the walls. The large amethyst 'cathedrals' in shops are sections cut from such cavities in Brazilian and Uruguayan basalt, and they are the commonest place to meet enhanced amethyst, because the piece is big, expensive and sold on colour.

Two treatments turn up. The first is dye, sprayed or soaked into pale material — look at the base of the crystals where they meet the rock, and into the crevices between points, because that is where dye pools. Natural colour is strongest in the outer tip of each crystal and fades towards its base, which is the opposite pattern. The second is heat, which turns amethyst to citrine; almost every large orange 'citrine cathedral' on the market is heated amethyst, and the honest ones say so.

Provenance genuinely matters for price here. Uruguayan material is typically deeper in colour with smaller, tighter crystals; Brazilian is usually paler with larger points. A vendor claiming Uruguayan depth at Brazilian prices is worth a second look at the crevices.

References and sizes

Uruguayan (deep, small crystals) · Brazilian (paler, larger crystals) · Cathedral / church

Establish which of these you are holding before judging it. A genuine piece read against another reference's rules will look wrong when it is not.

Model-specific checks

What decides a Amethyst Geode & Cathedral

These apply to this model and not to the rest of Amethyst. Work them alongside the maker's general checks, not instead of them.

01Decisive

Look where the crystals meet the rock

In natural material each crystal is deepest at its tip and pales towards its base, because the iron concentrated in the last-grown layers. Dyed geodes show the reverse: colour pooled down in the gaps between points and at the roots, where the liquid ran and settled.

02Strong

Wipe a hidden crystal with acetone on a cotton bud

On a surface-dyed piece, some dyes lift onto the swab. Do it somewhere that will not be seen, and take a clean result as inconclusive rather than as proof — many dyes are fast once dry.

03Strong

Treat a bright orange 'citrine cathedral' as heated amethyst

Natural citrine of that size and saturation is rare to the point of near-absence. Look at the base of the piece and in shadowed pockets for surviving purple, which is the direct evidence of what it was before the kiln.

The market

What a Amethyst Geode & Cathedral does on the secondary market

Priced by size, colour depth and crystal quality. Small geodes are tens of dollars; large deep-purple Uruguayan cathedrals reach four figures.

An orientation for honest, unrestored condition — never an appraisal, and never a quotation.

Questions we are asked

Are amethyst geodes dyed?
Some are, and it is worth checking on any large piece sold on colour. Natural amethyst is deepest at each crystal's tip and pales towards the base; dyed material shows colour pooled in the crevices between crystals and at their roots, where the dye ran.
Is a citrine geode real citrine?
Almost never. Large bright-orange 'citrine' cathedrals are heat-treated amethyst — the same mineral, with the iron converted by heat. It is a long-standing and legitimate treatment, but it should be disclosed, and surviving purple in shadowed pockets usually gives it away.
Why is Uruguayan amethyst more expensive?
Colour depth. Uruguayan material typically runs deeper purple with smaller, tighter crystal points, which is the look the market pays for. Brazilian geodes are generally paler with larger crystals and are correspondingly cheaper.
The Lovenhall RegistryLovenhall Stone

Read the stone itself

The tests tell you what it is. The instrument reads a photograph and offers a name to start from — then hands you back to the tile and the coin, which are what settle it.

Free on iPhone & iPad. An estimate, never an appraisal.
Or write to the house